Are Vans Better Than Pickups?

Are Vans Better Than Pickups?

Go ahead, think inside the box.


2019 Mercedes Benz Sprinter 2500 4×4

I love a good pickup, but vans such as the Mercedes-Benz Sprinter 4×4 have me convinced that what consumers really need is a good full-size van and not one of the hundreds of thousands of pickups our compatriots buy each year. While pickups have—for better or worse—become quicker, more luxurious, and more technologically advanced, vans such as the third-generation 2019 Mercedes-Benz Sprinter 4×4 have remained laser-focused on one thing: work.


Sprinting to Work

I probably alienated five out of every four pickup buyers with my previous paragraph, but when it comes to actual work, the only thing a pickup can really do better than a van is tow a heavier load; when it comes to hauling, the van is king.


Right Arrow

You have the Sprinter to thank for that. Many of you may remember the Dodge Sprinter of the early aughts. A replacement for the Dodge Ram Van, the Dodge Sprinter—essentially little more than a first-generation Mercedes-Benz Sprinter with a crosshair grille—introduced consumers to the wonders of a European-style van. Compared to the pickup-based doghouse-style vans on our roads at the time (think Ford Econoline/E-Series, or the current Chevrolet Express, which coincidentally hasn’t changed much since its 1995 launch), the Sprinter was purpose-built from the ground up to be a van. It was available as a cargo or passenger van with multiple lengths and roof heights (allowing people to stand up straight inside), with slab sides and a stubby hood that hid a diesel engine underneath to maximize space and performance.

Although the Sprinter never outsold the venerable Econoline/E-Series, it did cause consumers to rethink what they wanted in a full-size van. Ford opted to kill off the E-Series in 2014 after 60 years of production in favor of the distinctly European-flavored Ford Transit (a van that coincidently the first-generation Sprinter was modeled after). With Daimler taking the Sprinter back after its split with Chrysler, the Dodge and Ram brands (now partnered with Fiat) tellingly opted to produce the Fiat Ducato as the Ram ProMaster. Nissan tried its hand at building a traditional pickup-based van, the NV.


Sprinting Toward A New Generation of Van

Finally facing some stiff competition by the Transit and ProMaster, the third-generation Sprinter reached our shores in 2019 and has been largely unchanged since.


There’s quite literally a Sprinter variant for every conceivable purpose—a cargo van, crew van (think crew cab pickup with an enclosed bed), chassis cab, and passenger van. Mercedes also offers two wheelbases (3.65 and 4.3metres), three different lengths (6, 7, and 7.3metres), and two different roof heights (regular and high). There are also three engine options (a gas, turbo 2.0-liter I-4 making 142Kw and 350Nm of torque; a turbo-diesel 2.0-liter I-4 making 120Kw and 360Kw; and a turbo-diesel 3.0-liter V-6 producing 142Kw and 439Kw) and two transmission choices (nine-speed auto for the gasser and seven-speed autos for the diesels). Rear-wheel drive is standard across the board, but the diesel V-6 model offers both all-wheel and four-wheel drive options.

We’ll skip diving deep into the variety of weight classes Mercedes offers for the Sprinter, but there are 1500-, 2500-, 3500-, and 4500-series vans, with the ability to tow up to 7,500 pounds or to haul 6,636 pounds—the latter figure will make a Ford Super Duty pickup blush.

The Sprinter has adaptive cruise control, lane-keep assist, and even the brand’s MBUX infotainment system, which works with a 10.4-inch touchscreen, are all available. And, although the cabin will never be as luxurious as something such as a GLE or GLS, its fit, finish, and materials quality easily matches that of models like the GLB.

You wouldn’t think so given its size, but shockingly this big Benz drives rather well. Engineered primarily for narrow European roads, the 2019 Sprinter van drives far smaller and, well, sportier than its height suggest.

The Sprinter’s slow-steering rack is both low-effort and accurate, allowing you to confidently place the van on the road, and the van’s power is pretty good, too. The carryover turbo-diesel V-6 is a hair laggy off the line, but the turbo comes on quickly just north of 1,000 rpm, providing a strong surge of torque that only begins to peter out around 5,000 rpm—just as the engine hits redline. Uncharacteristically for a diesel, the Sprinter’s V-6 tends to rev quickly, and it reveals itself to be plenty potent even when the van is loaded with cargo.

The Sprinter’s new transmission has a lot to do with that. A welcome improvement over the old five-speed unit, the new seven-speed automatic features short gear ratios and upshifts quickly, helping the van get off the line far quicker than you’d expect. The new gearbox has an annoying tendency to upshift early on long uphill grades, but it responds quickly to downshift requests, delivered via standard steering-wheel-mounted paddle shifters.

At the test track, the Mercedes-Benz Sprinter 4×4 accelerated from 0 to 100 km/h in 11.6 seconds and on through the 400metre peg in 18.3 seconds at 117km/h. That’s a solid improvement on the last-generation Sprinter, the quickest of which (a rear-drive Sprinter 2500 passenger van with the diesel V-6) accelerated to 100km/h in 12.4 seconds and through the quarter in 18.7 seconds at 116 km/h. It’s also a fair bit quicker than the recently discontinued Ford Transit diesel (12.5 seconds to 100km/h for a Transit 350 cargo van), but far slower than any Transit equipped with the optional twin-turbo 3.5-liter V-6. The last one of those we tested, a passenger van, hit 100km/h in 9.4 seconds with 10 passengers on board; with just a driver, its quickest run was an impressive 7.6 seconds.



Aided by its good brake feel, the 2019 Sprinter 4×4’s best 100km/h panic stop measured 41metres, while it lapped our figure-eight course in 34.2 seconds averaging 0.41 g.

The van’s four-wheel-drive setup is mechanically identical to the system used on the previous-generation Sprinter 4×4—which could be a shockingly capable off-roader when equipped with all-terrain tires (and provided you choose your path carefully to mitigate its middling breakover angle). Like the old Sprinter 4×4, the new one gets a suspension lift and an all-wheel-drive system that’s engaged via a small black chiclet of a button with hieroglyphics, located near the driver’s right knee.

Tapping the button turns on a little red light, signifying all-wheel drive is engaged (with a 35:65 front and rear torque split). Opting for the aforementioned low-range package nets the Sprinter 4×4 a proper four-wheel-drive system, with a two-speed transfer case and a low-range that’s engaged via another chiclet button (and a 50:50 torque split). Unlike a G-Wagen, no locking differentials are available on the Sprinter 4×4. All diff “locking” comes via a brake-based system tied into the van’s electronic stability- and traction-control systems.


A Van Worth Sprinting For?

The Sprinter 4×4 is pricey, but with the average new pickup (including midsize, full-size, and heavy-duty) selling for more than $50,000, the Sprinter’s pricing is competitive with bigger, more capable trucks. While the Sprinter’s towing capacity may never match that of full-size and heavy-duty pickups, the Sprinter 4×4’s unique combination of utility, payload capacity, and off-road capability—not to mention its relative efficiency and maneuverability—make it an enticing choice for those who can think outside the box. Or, more appropriately, inside it.

Share the Post

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *